Your cart is currently empty!
Rent or Buy a Water Softener? Cost, Pros & How to Choose!
Whenever our clients plan to get a water softener, the most important question they ask is “whether to rent or buy a water softener,” and the decision is not always straightforward. See, it involves many factors, including your budget, the cost of a water softener, the amount of water required, and, most importantly, how long you need a water softener for.
For long-term use, buying a softener is always a good option. However, if you are unaware of the process of figuring out your requirements, here’s our complete step-by-step guide.
Whenever you are in a fix on whether to rent or buy a water softener and want to know how to decide, make a few calculations before making a final decision. Here is a comparison of renting a water softener vs buying.
| Factor | Buying a Water Softener | Renting a Water Softener |
| Initial Cost | High upfront (ranging from $500 to $10,000) | Low ($100) to none |
| Monthly Cost | None (after purchase) | $20-$100 |
| Maintenance Responsibility | Owner’s responsibility after warranty expires | Covered by the rental company |
| Installation Fees | $150–$1,000 | Included in the rental package |
| Ownership | Full ownership | Property of the rental company |
| Contract Length | None | High; easier to cancel or upgrade |
| Long-Term Cost | Low | High (if it’s over 5 years) |
| Repairs & Savings | The owner pays after the warranty ends | Included in the rental |
| Best For | Homeowners or those staying over 5 years | Renters or those staying less than 5 years |
Water Softener Rental vs Purchase: Which Option Is Best?
A water softener is a huge investment, surely. Depending upon your lifestyle, you need to figure out carefully whether to rent or buy a water softener. Hard water can shorten the life of water heaters and washing machines — see how hard water impacts appliances. As a thumb rule, if you have shifted to a place with hard water for a shorter period, rent a water softener, look around, and see the companies that offer rented softeners.
But, on the other hand, if you have bought a new property in a hard water area, and you are planning to live there for the rest of your life, or at least permanent residence, we suggest you choose a water softener that fits your needs and own it to avoid overly spending in terms of the rental amount.
At WaterMart, we help our customers estimate their needs and install high-technology Water Filtration Systems, including water softeners of all capacities. We ensure quality water filters that keep you healthy and hydrated while being economical for your budget. Before you plan to buy a water softener or rent one, let’s discuss all the pros and cons of each.
When Renting a Water Softener Might Be Right for You
Our advice is to go for rented water softeners in case you need a short-term solution for hard water. Or if you want to test a water softener, before making a purchase, rent it and use it for some months. It can save you money and help you decide whether to make a long-term investment or not.
Budget-Friendly
Rented softeners are budget-friendly and don’t cost you an arm and a leg. You can get a rental service at $25-$50 per month.
When You’re Renting Your Home or Plan to Move Soon
If you plan to move or rent out your permanent residence, you may get a water softener for rent. It will help you save money, and you can discontinue the agreement as soon as you leave your property.
Short-Term Commitment
Rented softeners work better for people who want temporary solutions. If you travel around a lot and rarely use your space, rented softeners will suffice. It will also help if your area has soft water naturally.
Low-Maintenance Solution
Rental agreements often include maintenance and repair services. This eliminates the hassle of upkeep and ensures your system stays functional, saving time and effort. It ends up saving you unexpected costs.
Testing the Waters
For first-time users, renting allows you to evaluate the system’s performance. It helps determine whether investing in a water softener suits your household needs before committing to a purchase. It ensures you test a functional system without additional effort.
Upgrade Flexibility
Whenever newer or more advanced water softener systems are introduced, rental plans allow easy upgrades. This adaptability allows for upgrades as your needs evolve. You can switch to newer models or higher-capacity systems without bearing the cost of purchasing entirely new equipment.
When Buying a Water Softener Might Be Right for You
Owning a water softener is ideal for homeowners seeking long-term reliability. The truth about rented systems is that they can cost more. Purchasing a new water softener system provides greater control and customization. Unlike renting, where costs accumulate, owning becomes more economical over time.
Long-Term Investment
Buying is cost-effective for extended use. For instance, a rental unit costing $40 per month will add up to $1,440 after three years, and this amount will keep increasing with time. Buying a system is an asset; it adds value to your property and ensures consistent water quality. Over time, it pays for itself, saving on rental fees.
Customization
With ownership, you have the flexibility to choose. Furthermore, there are various types of water softeners on the market. When renting, you often have to choose from the options provided by your rental company, which are limited. A new system means picking the best model (out of dozens) tailored to your household’s specific needs.
Complete Control Over Maintenance
Owning a water softener gives you control over its care. With us, you can decide on maintenance service schedules, ensuring the system runs efficiently and meets your expectations. It ensures repairs are done promptly without being late or dependent on third parties.
Long-Term Reliability
Unlike rented systems that include repairs and maintenance, the purchase comes with a warranty. This warranty covers parts and labor for a specified period, alleviating concerns about unexpected repairs or issues. Unlike rental units, which may be pre-used or outdated, your purchased unit is brand new, making it a reliable solution for your home.
Tax Incentives
Filtered soft water in houses improves health. Installing a water softener system offers additional benefits, such as being tax-deductible if it meets guidelines. This financial advantage is just one of the many water softener benefits, and we also research local regulations to help you save more.
What Is Included In A Water Softener Rental Agreement?
Renting a water softener means you are paying for the company’s service, not just their unit. Therefore, most rental agreements include the essentials to keep your system running efficiently. Typical rental agreements cover:
- Installation costs: Set up by certified technicians.
- Regular maintenance: Includes inspections, cleanings, and salt refills.
- Repairs: Faulty parts and service are usually covered.
- No long‑term lock‑in: Easy cancellation after the minimum term (cancel after 12 months)
- Model flexibility: Select a model that fits your home’s size and water needs.
- Custom plans: Many providers offer rental terms tailored to your home and usage.
- Easy upgrades: Some plans allow upgrades or swaps as your needs evolve.
Want the full breakdown of fees or terms? Just give a call to WaterMart and we’ll provide the complete rental contract, including water softener installation costs, monthly payments, and any minimum rental period.
At WaterMart, our team helps you find the right water softener type (depending on your budget) and size (based on the water’s hardness). We also offer maintenance plans, including salt refills and replacement parts. Since policies may vary, get in contact with us for both new and used units to ensure the perfect water softener size for your needs.
What Are the Cost Differences Between Buying and Renting a Water Softener System?
Purchasing a new water softener costs approximately $500 to $2000. The cost increases based on the system’s size and features. For smaller homes with modest water usage, a lower-cost water softener suffices. Likewise, larger households require a more expensive model.
On the other hand, water softener rental costs typically range from $20 to $50 per month. The cost is also based on the required size. Here’s a table to see the difference.
| Type | Initial cost | Installation cost | 2 year | 3 year | 10 year | Maintenance cost | Total over 10 years |
| Rental | $40 | $500 | $960 | $1,440 | $4,800 | $0 | $5,300 ($4,800 + $500) |
| New | $1,500 | $1,000 | $2,500 | $2,500 | $2,500 | $250 (per year) | $5,000 (2,500 + $2,500) |
Note! Based on our calculations, if you want to use a water softener for more than 3 years, purchasing a new unit is more cost-effective.
How To Choose The Right Company To Buy Or Rent a Water Softener
Whether you’re buying or renting a water softener for your household, the right company is the most important part of the contract or purchase. Do not blindly trust a company with your home’s water quality, long-term system reliability, and overall cost. The checklist below helps you separate a dependable provider from one that could cost you later.
- Choose a company with local experience and verified reviews from real long-term water softener customers.
- Ask for total pricing upfront, including install, salt delivery, maintenance, and any cancellation fees.
- Make sure they offer multiple models for different water hardness levels and home sizes.
- Check that ongoing maintenance, salt refills, and urgent repairs are included or clearly priced.
- Look for short-term rental options with easy upgrades, cancellation, or relocation flexibility if needed.
Need A Water Softener? Contact WaterMart Today
Confused about water softener rental vs purchase, go by this rule: renting suits short-term needs, while buying is a long-term investment. But for how long? If you want to use a unit for less than 3 years, a rental unit is a better investment. For more than that, buy the right system tailored to your home with WaterMart. We will assess your budget, duration of use, and household needs to decide and pick the right water softener system.
FAQS
What is the downside of a water softener?
Water softeners involve the risk of a higher amount of sodium in soft water. It also pollutes the environment in the form of salt discharge. There is also corrosion of pipes involved, so always consider the after-math before installing a water softener.
How long do water softeners last?
A water softener usually lasts for more than 15-20 years. Careful maintenance can prolong its lifespan by up to 25 years. If your unit is facing unusual wear and tear, then consider your maintenance schedule again and establish some KPIs.
Can I switch from renting to owning a water softener later?
Yes, you can always switch from renting the water softener to owning it by purchasing it. If the company is not selling you the same unit you have been renting, simply end your rental contract with the company and buy a new water softener unit that meets your requirements.
Is installation included if I rent or buy a water softener?
Installation may or may not be included in the rental or purchasing price of a water softener. Make sure to check the pricing breakdown first before you make the final decision.
Would I buy or rent a water softener?
We recommend buying a water softener if you plan to use it for the long term, however, you can get rental services to test the water softener before making a final decision.
